Y’all are missing the bigger picture here. This brings up the question of ai and intellectual property and throws the ball into adobe’s court to set their army of lawyers on figuiring out a no-win solution for themselves.
If they do nothing, a working clone normalizes copying their product’s behavior and UI. Copyright covers that thinly anyway (the First Circuit in Lotus v. Borland treated a command menu hierarchy as an unprotectable method of operation). Trademarks need policing!! (And they suck)
If they go after it, they have to argue in court that AI output built from public material is infringing or derivative. That’s the precedent the AI industry wants to avoid, and it cuts against Adobe’s own Firefly pitch. Imagine what that means for “art” made with an LLM
If the clone’s code is mostly AI-written, its copyrightability is shaky (Copyright Office, Thaler). But that cuts both ways: Adobe can’t claim “you stole our code” without proving actual copied code. Which bites into OpenAI, Anthropic, Google’s claims that they haven’t stolen anything.
Edit: Sorry I should’ve used Super Intelligence, I don’t want to be the enemy. /s
Yeah this would be great if it went that way but really the other option more likely to happen is they settle and the guy goes away quietly and nothing comes of it as their SLAP lawsuit works like a charm.
Y’all are missing the bigger picture here. This brings up the question of ai and intellectual property and throws the ball into adobe’s court to set their army of lawyers on figuiring out a no-win solution for themselves.
Edit: Sorry I should’ve used Super Intelligence, I don’t want to be the enemy. /s
Yeah this would be great if it went that way but really the other option more likely to happen is they settle and the guy goes away quietly and nothing comes of it as their SLAP lawsuit works like a charm.
Settle what? What’s the outcome of the settlement. Even that sets a precedent.
The Kind of we will drop our suit if you give us your code etc.
I really don’t think any of this is intentional, though. It’s just the contradictions being heightened.
it was guaranteed to happen. didn’t need to be masterminded, but the target points to forethought.