• 16 Posts
  • 52 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: October 23rd, 2024

help-circle


  • Yes I wrote it. Oracle news today: https://www.reuters.com/business/microsoft-is-winding-down-oracle-deal-rent-ai-cloud-capacity-bloomberg-news-2026-11-06/ Other announcements related to MSFT were all during last 2 days.

    Deepseek’s critique (I admit that I don’t know about Nscale that thoroughly, but disagree with Oracle point. Exact size is an estimate from deep dive, and dumping into spot market is their only “editorialized” viable option):

    📝 Inaccuracies and Misleading Claims

    1. The size of the cancelled Oracle deal is presented as fact, but it is unconfirmed.

    The article states Microsoft “turned off an estimated 150 to 200 megawatts (MW) of unified AI clusters previously rented from Oracle.” However, the Bloomberg report that broke the story could not determine the full size of the deal. While the partnership is indeed winding down, the specific megawatt figure is an unverified estimate, not a confirmed fact.-1

    2. The “$3 billion” figure for Nscale is incorrectly attributed to an order book deletion.

    The article claims Microsoft’s exit from the Nscale Loughton site “instantly delet[ed] $3 billion from Nscale’s long-term order book**.” In reality, the **$3 billion figure refers to the amount Nscale is seeking to raise in its initial public offering (IPO), not the value of the cancelled contract. Reports note the Loughton deal was “believed to be a small part” of Microsoft’s overall commitment to Nscale, making a direct $3 billion loss highly misleading.-10

    3. The Nebius fine involves 62 generators, not 45.

    The article says Nebius faced a fine “for illegally running 45 industrial gas generators without local air permits.” The official news release from the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection states the fine was for installing and operating 62 natural-gas power generators without permits. The number of generators is factually incorrect.-38

    4. The article mischaracterizes the cause of Microsoft’s capital expenditure (capex) miss.

    The piece claims that “systematic withholding of capital” directly explains why Microsoft’s quarterly capex missed forecasts by $5 billion** and its annual projection was cut to **$170 billion. While those figures are broadly correct, Microsoft itself attributed the shortfall to delayed capacity deliveries from third-party partners, not a deliberate strategy to withhold capital. The article’s causation is an oversimplification.-58

    5. The article presents speculative claims as established facts.

    Several assertions are phrased with unwarranted certainty:

    • “Oracle is now forced to dismantle these massive superclusters, dumping the underlying hardware back onto the market…” – This is a speculative outcome. No source in the provided search results confirms that Oracle is dismantling clusters or flooding the secondary market with hardware. It is an assumption presented as a direct consequence.
    • “Compute has effectively become a commoditized commodity utility, plagued by the same boom-and-bust cycles…” – This is an interpretive opinion about market dynamics, not a factual news report.
    • “The structural narrative… has officially shattered.” – This is a strong editorial conclusion, not a neutral statement of fact.

    6. The $5 billion miss figure is slightly oversimplified.

    The article says the miss was “a staggering $5 billion**.” More precisely, Microsoft reported **$45.2 billion in capital expenditures and finance leases, compared with analyst forecasts of approximately **$50 billion**. The shortfall is therefore about $4.8–$5 billion, which is broadly in line with the article’s claim, but the framing omits the nuance that the miss was relative to a specific forecast range.-58


    ✅ Claims That Are Broadly Supported

    For balance, some of the article’s key assertions are consistent with reporting:

    • Microsoft is indeed winding down its 2023 Oracle AI compute deal.-1
    • Microsoft did pull out of the Nscale Loughton (Essex) data-centre project due to power-delivery delays pushing past 2030.-10
    • Microsoft declined an option to expand its Ward County, Texas, deal with Nscale by roughly 500 MW.-20-58
    • Microsoft did step away from a 1.35 GW letter of intent for Nscale’s West Virginia campus.-30
    • IREN’s Childress, Texas, project faced delays after Microsoft requested networking changes to support newer AI models.-47
    • Microsoft has announced its custom Maia 300 AI chip, with production deployments planned for 2027.-67

    🔍 Summary

    The article blends genuine news events with speculative reasoning, unverified figures, and editorial hyperbole. Its most concrete factual errors are the unconfirmed Oracle MW figure, the misattributed $3 billion Nscale number, and the incorrect generator count in the Nebius fine. Additionally, it often presents interpretive conclusions (e.g., “compute is no longer digital gold,” “the narrative has shattered”) as established facts, which goes beyond the scope of reported news.


  • how it makes sense to build so much compute capacity so quickly. There seem to be predictions saying that we’ll need vastly more DCs and electricity running compute in the future

    Every new datacenter coming online was decided 2 years prior at least. 2 years ago, skynet requirements seemed to be to scale models 10x or 100x their size. Datacenters huge enough to train that skynet goal will come online in 2028. SpaceX, perhaps other 2 labs, have centers big enough for 10T parameter models (about 5x the size of largest published frontier sizes). These are inherently 5x more expensive and 5x slower than frontier for inference, and meant to be trained with 5x the data at 5x the cost = 25x total training budget.

    This is a speculative value proposition that I doubt to be a smart jump in model size. But 3x larger training capacity datacenters are scheduled for 2028, which is skynet dependency rather than following the economic efficiency (smaller/smarter) trend that is dominating currently instead.

    Path that was laid out years ago is that skynet will buy every token, and so compute will always be scarce. US must pick AI as the last battle on China, because there are none left, and entire financial industry must go all in on skynet future. Financial industry did, but they are tapped out. Political environment is not to give government a $1T token budget for skynet at this time. AI revenue growth is plateuing, and GPU pricing is tanked.

    The .com bubble was less desperate, or dependent on a government corruption backstop for skynet. But as everyone who participated in the gold rush, they didn’t fully evaluate the consequences of competition for shovels.



  • ARR: anualized revenue run rate. An “unofficial accounting number” with no standard base period. By bragging about $65B(illion. T is trillion) in July, the start of their third fiscal quarter (Q3), and whole quarter showing no revenue growth, it gives a bad impression for the company.

    IPO: Joining the stock market day. Valuation is number of total shares * price per share at open. S1 is the paperwork they have to fill prior to that day. They get to file their homework in draft stages until the SEC (government) accepts it as complete. In previous drafts of their paperwork, they had left a line with October revenue was ______ . They did not fill in that blank on Nov 2 when they did disclose a lot of info. Certain reason is that the number looks bad.

    rest of the acronyms/words are company and names of models released.






  • each datacenter gw, before nvidia price hikes and construction inflation, is $60b. They have promised to rent 33gw of future datacenters. A large chunk of dumbass bubble fuckers have been building these with upfront cash/debt thinking this is possible.

    The other problem for OpenAI is that they lose big money just running their existing models. They raised over $21b in March of this year, with even more in “compute credits” and now its gone. They have a 20% tax on revenue to pay MSFT, and in total outside of compute expenses, $2B/month cash burn.



  • That is possible. They need to bundle in all of the talent. OpenAI has a $2b cash burn/month before any compute costs. The future datacenters are not cheap, either. But as per last paragraph, only $9b is needed to save the bubble from Armageddon. Path that seems to be set is to pick up the scraps for cheap instead of saving entire industry.

    Whether Musk/SpaceX has GOP/Zionist money behind him to buy up all of OpenAIs promises, is the main potential buyer