

This is a pretty weird analogy… So A.I. is a centaur if you use it to great effect as a force multiplier to increase your output and everything works out. But you’re a reverse centaur if you do the same thing but it ends up bad. The example given is a bestselling book list that normally takes a whole team to write up. Instead one person was tasked to do it but they fucked up because they didn’t check if the books even existed and accidentally recommended fake books. The only difference to make them a “centaur” is if they or the A.I. didn’t fuck up.
I do agree that there are some people who are essentially meat puppets of machines and do everything the machine tells them to. But it doesn’t make sense in a productivity setting. It’s more like both people are centaurs but one of them crashed into a wall and the other ran safely 3x faster



Yeah I just feel like the example given doesn’t line up that well. There’s no difference between his good example and bad example other than having a human perform quality control, that doesn’t make it a reverse centaur situation.
The example given is more like… unsupervised horses on typewriters. The A.I. owns the process from start to end, and the human just clicks “upload” and trusts that the horse wrote a good article about books that it cannot comprehend in the first place. You can’t trust the A.I. to do a good job unsupervised, at least not yet.
A better example of reversed centaur is a lot trickier to define… it’s about an inversion of control. The A.I. making the executive and high level decisions, while the human does the grunt work like a meat puppet. We don’t have a lot of that to work with (yet). But with the same book article example, I can imagine something like:
The human asks the A.I. what kind of article to write, and also asks the A.I. to do all the research. The human manually writes a bad stupid article based on fake data. Maybe the A.I. also puts in something that gets the human in trouble like unknowingly recommending some hentai in the romance section. The human is doing the grunt work, while the A.I. steers them towards a cliff face.